How to choose a scented candle: what to look for, from a candle maker in Cork
Two scented candles can look identical on a shelf and be completely different once you light them. After a long time spent testing scents for our own candles here in East Cork, these are the things I would check before buying one, from us or from anyone else.
1. The wax
This is the part most people never look at, and it decides a lot. Paraffin is petroleum derived and is still the most common candle wax. Plant based waxes are the alternative.
If a label just says "wax" or "a wax blend", it is fair to ask what is in it. Ours is 100% plant based, with no paraffin anywhere in the candle. If you are comparing pearled candles with sand candles, which look very similar, this comparison explains why the wax is the real difference.
2. The fragrance
A few things worth looking for:
- Where it is made. Ours are made in Grasse, in France, the world's perfume capital.
- Phthalate free. Phthalates are a group of chemicals that many people now prefer to avoid in their homes.
- CMR free. CMR means carcinogenic, mutagenic and reprotoxic, the European classification for substances you would rather not have around. A fragrance free from CMR classified ingredients avoids them.
- Vegan and cruelty free, if that matters to you.
Then there is how the fragrance behaves in that particular wax. A scent that works beautifully in a jar candle does not always work in another format, which is why I test each scent specifically for pearled wax before it goes anywhere near the shop.
3. The safety label
Many scented candles sold in Ireland carry a small panel with warning symbols and a list of fragrance allergens. That comes from EU labelling rules, known as CLP, and it does not mean the candle is a bad one. It is useful, though: if you or someone you are buying for reacts to certain fragrance ingredients, that list is where to check.
4. How strong you want it
Candle makers talk about two kinds of scent. Cold throw is what you smell before lighting. Hot throw is what fills the air once it is burning.
Here is the honest version for our candles: pearled wax has a gentle hot throw. It scents the space around it softly rather than filling the house, and adding more wicks gives a stronger scent. If you want a room scented strongly, all day, a reed diffuser does that better than any candle we make, and each of ours is paired with a candle scent.
5. The format
A jar candle is the familiar choice. A pearled candle is different: the wax comes as pearls you pour into any heat resistant bowl, add a wick and light. It is refillable, so there is no jar to throw away, it does not tunnel, and if it gets knocked over it simply goes out, because there is no pool of hot liquid wax. The full comparison is in pearled candle vs jar candle.
6. The scent itself
Most fragrances are described in three stages. Ours are written as First, Then and Last:
- First is what you notice straight away, usually the lightest notes.
- Then is the heart of the scent, once it settles.
- Last is the deeper part that stays in the room.
So The Good Room opens with cardamom and cedar, settles into oud and cashmere wood, and finishes on musk and amber. If you are not sure what you like, the find your scent quiz is a good place to start.
A quick checklist
- Is the wax named? Is there paraffin in it?
- Is the fragrance phthalate free and CMR free?
- Does the label carry safety and allergen information?
- Do you want a gentle scent around you, or a whole room filled? (Candle or diffuser.)
- Can it be refilled, or will there be a jar to throw away?
If you would like to see how ours measure up, here is what goes into our scented candles, made in Cork, or see the Christmas baubles.
Mel 💛
